Back to Homepage / Blogs / Dec 2019
Issues in India
No one said going back into India
would be easy. Having pioneered Ganges
cruising ten years ago we had some experience of the challenges of setting up in India. However, reforms under
Premier MODI have made investing and operating in India simpler and safer so we decided to give it another go and three
ultra-shallow draft vessels were towed by tug over from Myanmar earlier this year, which in itself was a story. Our first
recce voyage on the Lower
Ganges last September went well, if a bit shambolically as a new crew on a new river found their feet.
Given the difficulties of management in India we appointed a local partner 'Indus Cruises' to manage the ships. Having just
come back from India myself I was very pleasantly surprised by their progress. Long experience of set ups on new rivers in new
destinations has taught me that it usually takes a year or two before a new routing streamlines. Indians are quick learners
and they are getting there fast.
The seven night Lower Ganges expedition is now running well and crew have got up to speed on the service side and the
excursions into the towns and villages of West Bengal get good feedback.
On the Upper
Ganges challenges abound: one moment too much water and the next too little; groundings on sand banks are
frequent; promised openings of pontoon bridges to allow us to pass can cause considerable delays.
This is not like cruising on the Rhine or Rhone, waterways with controlled flows and regulated levels. These are extreme
rivers. For example, on the Irrawaddy there are places where the water level goes up 60m in the monsoon. In Cambodia we
navigate a major river that twice a year actually reverses direction. On the Chindwin river our 90cm draft vessels scrape through
labyrinthine shoals only a meter deep, guided by sailors poling with bamboos. For twenty-five years Pandaw have specialised in remote river expeditions. These are
intended to be adventurous. It is what we do. To reinforce this we have very clear messages on our website warning passengers
about the challenges ahead: groundings are every day events; that if there is too much or too little water the voyage may be
curtailed and land arrangements made to make connections; that all itineraries are indicational only and subject to almost
daily revision, depending on the state of the river. Pandaw passengers relish these challenges and keep coming back for not
just the excitement but the exceptional level of care they receive on our ships.
For India, we make it very clear on our website that the ships are not managed by us but by an appointed local partner. We
explain that the service style may not be up to what our regular travellers have been accustomed to on our well-honed
expeditions in South-East Asia. We ask all bookers sign a waiver to say they understand this and fearful that passengers may
not have read this properly we even wrote to everyone before the cruise with an additional advisory and an offer of a full
refund if passengers preferred to cancel in view of this.
Last week we received some very negative press coverage from a journalist travelling as our guest on the Kindat Pandaw on the Upper Ganges and in
the UK an article appeared in the Sunday Times over a collision with a bridge.
Following our investigation, which has included interviews with the master and other key crew members, we have established
that that the ship accidentally bumped into a pontoon or floating bridge that was about to be opened to allow passage through.
The hull was holed above the waterline with a gash of about 20cm and a very small amount of water entered the sealed hull
compartment. Bilge pumps were immediately activated. These ships are designed to cop e with water ingress and have water-tight
bulkheads and bilge pumps. Collisions on busy waterways do occasionally happen, usually with other vessels, and crew can
temporarily patch any hole in a moment using patch kits we carry on our ships.
In this case the tour guide, who is a freelancer, panicked and ordered the evacuation of the ship. This should have been
the master's decision not the guide's. It could be argued that this was a correct precautionary measure, but it was a complete
overreaction. It caused considerable distress for the passengers. For this we can only apologise. What was a relatively minor
incident quickly became a drama. We are really sorry that the passengers had this experience.
THE KINDAT AND THE PONTOON. THE SMALL HOLE CAN BE
SEEN STAUNCHED WITH A TOWEL
Learning from this experience, we are working with our Indian partners on improving crew training to ensure such a panic
does not happen again and that there is a clear chain of command.
We are also revising the Upper Ganges itinerary to avoid the section with the pontoon bridges and will transfer passengers
overland for the final leg between Ghazipur and Varanasi.
Working with the IWAI (Inland Waterway of India) we are making good progress on improving navigational aids and channel
markings. IWAI have been incredibly helpful supplying us with expert pilots and pilot boats.
We at Pandaw pride ourselves on our safety record and the professionalism of our crews. A common comment on passenger
feedback is the excellent seamanship of our river masters. Other than one minor incident eighteen years ago in Vietnam (when
we hit a fish farm), we have never made an insurance claim, nor have we ever been sued by anyone, and only once ever evacuated
a ship as a precaution when we had a cyclone warning on the Chindwin, and that was many years ago.
India by river really is the only way to do it – the scenery is incredible, the culture dazzling and there is just so much
to see and do. To get our ships there running to the standards of what we do in Myanmar, Laos, Cambodia or Vietnam will take time but I have
complete confidence in our Indian partners and know that with the support and encouragement of our Pandaw regulars it will not
be difficult.
Paul Strachan
